You're putting money aside for your first home and can't decide between the FHSA and the TFSA? Both accounts grow your savings tax-free, but they don't work the same way. For a down payment, it all comes down to two things: the tax deduction when you contribute, and what you can do with the money if your plans change.

In short: if you qualify, the FHSA has an edge the TFSA doesn't. Your contributions are tax-deductible, and a qualifying withdrawal to buy your home isn't taxed. The TFSA's strength is flexibility: you withdraw whenever you want, for any purpose, and the room comes back the following year. The most effective approach is often to use both: the FHSA first, up to $8,000 a year, then the TFSA for the rest.

FHSA vs TFSA: side-by-side comparison

Rules summarized as of November 17, 2026, based on the Canada Revenue Agency. Full conditions are on the CRA website.
FHSATFSA
Who can open oneFirst-time home buyers only (see below)Any Canadian resident aged 18 or older
2026 limit$8,000$7,000
Lifetime limit$40,000None: the annual limit is added every year
Room builds upFrom the day you open your first accountFrom age 18, even without an account
Unused roomCarried forward, up to $8,000Carried forward in full
Tax deductionYes, federally and in Quebec, and it can be carried forward to a later yearNo
Withdrawal to buyTax-free if it's a qualifying withdrawal (form RC725), nothing to pay backTax-free, nothing to pay back
Withdrawal for anything elseTaxable: the amount is added to your incomeTax-free; the amount withdrawn is added back to your room on January 1 of the following year
Contribution deadlineDecember 31: no 60-day window like the RRSPNone, since unused room carries forward
How long it lastsMust be closed by December 31 of the year of its 15th anniversary, the year you turn 71, or the year after your first qualifying withdrawalNo limit
If you don't buyDirect transfer to an RRSP or RRIF, with no immediate tax and no effect on your RRSP roomThe money stays in your TFSA

Why the FHSA has the edge for a down payment

In both accounts, your investments grow tax-free, and the withdrawal you use to buy your home isn't taxed (for the FHSA, as long as it's a qualifying withdrawal). The real difference is on the way in: an FHSA contribution is deducted from your income, like an RRSP contribution. A TFSA contribution isn't.

For the same savings, the FHSA therefore cuts your taxes: roughly your marginal tax rate times the contribution you deduct. The table shows the order of magnitude.

Approximate tax savings by combined marginal rate (federal and Quebec). The rates are round examples: yours depends on your income. Assumption: the deduction is claimed in the year of the contribution.
Marginal rate (example)One year at the limit ($8,000)Lifetime limit ($40,000)
30%$2,400$12,000
40%$3,200$16,000
50%$4,000$20,000

You can save those tax savings too, for example in your TFSA, to grow your down payment. And if your income is low this year, you don't have to claim the deduction right away. You can contribute to the FHSA now and deduct later, in a year when your rate is higher: undeducted contributions carry forward, even after the account is closed.

Who qualifies for an FHSA?

To open an FHSA, you must not have lived, as your principal residence, in a home that you or your current spouse or common-law partner owned, in the current year or the previous 4 calendar years. At withdrawal time, the test applies to you only, and the 30 days before the withdrawal don't count. The TFSA has no home-buying condition at all. Everything about the FHSA →

When the TFSA is still the right choice

  • You don't qualify for the FHSA, for example because you lived in a home you owned in the last 4 calendar years.
  • You've maxed out the FHSA: $8,000 a year (up to $16,000 with carried-forward room) and $40,000 over your lifetime. The rest of your savings can go to the TFSA.
  • The money might be needed for something else than a home or your retirement. An FHSA withdrawal that isn't qualifying is taxable, while a TFSA withdrawal is tax-free at any time.
  • For your post-purchase cushion. The FHSA must be closed by December 31 of the year after your first qualifying withdrawal. Your homeowner reserve fund therefore belongs in a TFSA.

The strategy that uses both

  1. As early as possible

    Open your FHSA, even with a small amount

    FHSA contribution room only starts building once you open your first account. An account opened this year already gives you $8,000 of room, and up to $8,000 carries forward if you don't use it.

  2. Before December 31

    Contribute to your FHSA for the current year

    An FHSA contribution counts for the calendar year in which it's made. Unlike the RRSP, a contribution made in January or February can't be deducted on the previous year's return.

  3. If you already have a TFSA

    Move part of your TFSA to your FHSA

    There's no direct transfer from a TFSA to an FHSA: direct transfers into an FHSA come from another FHSA or from an RRSP. You can, however, withdraw from your TFSA and then contribute to your FHSA, within your room. The contribution becomes deductible, and the amount withdrawn from the TFSA is added back to your TFSA room on January 1 of the following year. Never go over your room: an excess costs 1% a month, in either account.

  4. Beyond the limit

    Put the surplus in your TFSA

    Once your FHSA is full for the year, the TFSA takes over for the rest of the down payment, closing costs and your reserve fund.

  5. When you buy

    Add the HBP if you have RRSPs

    A qualifying FHSA withdrawal can be combined with the Home Buyers' Plan for the same home. See how to combine the FHSA and the HBP →

As a couple, each of you has your own FHSA and your own TFSA, with your own limits. If you buy together, you can both make a qualifying withdrawal from your own FHSA for the same home, as long as each of you meets all the conditions.

What if you end up not buying?

That's the worry that pushes many people toward the TFSA. Yet money in an FHSA that isn't used to buy a home isn't lost. It can be transferred directly to your RRSP or RRIF, with no immediate tax and without reducing your RRSP contribution room (form RC721). The transfer has to go from one institution to the other: if you withdraw the money yourself and then deposit it in your RRSP, the withdrawal becomes taxable.

Uncertainty about when you'll buy is therefore not, on its own, a reason to prefer the TFSA. The TFSA is still the better place for money you might need for a project other than a home or retirement.

To find out how much you need to save for your target price, use our down payment calculator. If you're unsure about the best split for your situation, talk to your financial institution or a financial planner.

Official sources (CRA): First Home Savings Account (FHSA), TFSA contribution room.

Frequently asked questions

FHSA or TFSA: which is better for buying a first home?

If you qualify, start with the FHSA in most cases: contributions are tax-deductible and a qualifying withdrawal to buy your home isn't taxed. The TFSA is a good fit for extra savings, money you might need for another project, and your reserve fund after the purchase.

Can you have a TFSA and an FHSA at the same time?

Yes. They're two separate accounts with separate limits: in 2026, $8,000 for the FHSA and $7,000 for the TFSA. You can contribute to both in the same year.

Can you transfer your TFSA to your FHSA?

Not as a direct transfer: direct transfers into an FHSA come from another FHSA or an RRSP. You can, however, withdraw from your TFSA and then contribute to your FHSA within your room. That contribution is deductible, and the amount withdrawn from the TFSA is added back to your TFSA room on January 1 of the following year.

What is the FHSA contribution deadline?

December 31. An FHSA contribution counts for the calendar year in which it's made: unlike the RRSP, a contribution made in the first 60 days of the year can't be deducted on the previous year's return.

This content is for information only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Amounts, limits and program criteria change regularly — confirm your situation with the relevant bodies (CRA, Revenu Québec, City of Montreal, CMHC) or a professional before making a decision.